Brief Psychoanalytic Therapy for children with depressive disorders aged 4-8 years - Evaluation of effectiveness, applicability, and indicative factors in a Randomized Controlled Trial
Research team: Dipl.-Psych. Sarah Bergmann, Dr. phil. Annette Klein, Dr. phil. Lars White, Prof. Dr. Kai von Klitzing
Psychodynamic approaches to treat children and adolescents are frequently used in child and adolescent psychiatry. However, there are only few studies that systemically evaluate the effectiveness of psychodynamic psychotherapies during childhood and adolescence (Windaus, 2005). In the context of treating children and adolescence at the department of our clinic, we developed and manualized the concept of the Short-term Psychoanalytic Child Therapy (PaCT; English manual: Göttken & von Klitzing, 2014). This form of therapy is based on psychoanalytic principles. It combines a therapeutic approach that focusses on the inner world of the child (interpersonal relationships, internal representations) with a consequent inclusion of the parents into the therapeutic process. In a previous study (Göttken, White, Klein, & von Klitzing, 2014), PaCT has shown to be effective in the treatment of children with anxiety disorders.
After the therapy, over 66 percent of children did not show an anxiety disorder (according to DSM IV, assessed with a standardized interview) anymore while during the waiting period for none of the wait-list patients a remission of symptoms occurred. Furthermore, also parents and caregivers / teachers reported a reduction of symptoms immediately after the end of the therapy and 6 months later (follow-up assessment).
The aims of the current study is to systematically evaluate PaCT in the treatment of depressive disorders in children aged 4 to 8 years by using a randomized controlled design including a wait-list control condition. As our intense previous studies on depressive disorders in preschoolers and primary school children (e.g. Otto et al., 2014, von Klitzing et al., 2014) have detected a relevant proportion of children with clinical and subclinical symptoms of depression, we see an urgent need to treat such children with PaCT and evaluate its effectiveness in this context.
PaCT comprises 20 - 25 weekly psychotherapeutic sessions conducted in alternating settings (parent-child together, child and parent, individually). During these sessions, therapist, parent, and child seek to identify and modify the core conflictual theme underlying the relationship and symptoms. During individual sessions including free play the therapist helps the child to work through the child's central conflicts. Depending on the organization of the child's personality, the therapist also uses techniques that promote mentalization. Every fourth session, sessions with the parents take place.
The sample of the planned study will include n=64 children with clinical symptoms of depression and their parents. First, we want to evaluate the effectiveness of PaCT in a pre-post comparison including all 64 children. Second, we want to compare a group of N= 32 children who will immediately receive the treatment with PaCT to a group of N=32 children who will be treated after a waiting period (randomized wait-list control condition). We hypothesize that compared to the wait-list group, PaCT will lead to a stronger decrease in depressive symptoms and disorders (according to DSM V). We will assess children before and after the therapy and the waiting period, respectively, as well as six months after the end of the therapy. We will also analyze changes that are connected to the specific factors of PaCT, e.g. improvement of the child's mentalization or improvement of emotional availability in the parent-child interaction. Furthermore, we will investigate the effects of these aspects on the outcomes of the therapy.
Funding body: Heidehof Foundation GmbH, Vereinigung Analytischer Kinder- und Jugendlichen-Psychotherapeuten in Deutschland e.V (VAKJP)
Project Period: 2017 - 2020